in thread "Physicalism and Questions of Identity": The same question can be asked about software or physical laws. Where is the software ? or where is gravity ? I think neither question is answerable. We see functional behaviour that can be described by software or physical laws. Maybe consciousness is in ... 7mo ago (collapse hidden) log in to judge received 1.8 1.8 The same question ca (view hidden) log in to judge received 1.8 1.8 Seems to me like gravity to you is not form but something else ? Or did you just want to give a credible answer to explain gravity ? For me, a credible explanation does not imply that something is not form. Otherwise, form could just be explained away.... 7mo ago (collapse hidden) log in to judge received 3.3 3.3 Seems to me like gra (view hidden) log in to judge received 3.3 3.3 Thanks for clarifying that form is meant literally. If you meant to clarify that form is a real principle in reality, I do not disagree with that statement. However, this still leaves me confused when I read >>2395 and >>2397.... 7mo ago (collapse hidden) log in to judge received 2.2 2.2 Thanks for clarifyin (view hidden) log in to judge received 2.2 2.2 Take the programming language that has a degree of independence from the substrate. We can take two different substrates made of two different materials. We can have two different substrates running the exact same software. These substrates will have a dif... 7mo ago (collapse hidden) log in to judge received 2.2 2.2 Take the programming (view hidden) log in to judge received 2.2 2.2